Locksmith tips by My Locksmith

How to Check a Rochester Locksmith Before You Hire One

When you are locked out, you do not have much time to research, and some of the worst operators in this trade count on that. A few minutes of checking before you give someone your address can save you from a bad job or a surprise bill. This guide applies to any locksmith in Rochester or Monroe County, including us.

Start here: New York State does not license locksmiths

Many people assume a state license is the first filter. In Rochester, there is no such filter. New York State issues no locksmith license. The only places in the state that require one are New York City and Nassau County. Anywhere in Monroe County, whether you are in the city, Greece or Webster, there is no license a locksmith could hold. A company that advertises one is either confused or hoping you will not check. You need to verify a business a different way.

Four things to ask for instead

These four questions take under a minute on the phone, and a real local business can answer all of them.

  • The legal business name. Ask what name will appear on your invoice, then look it up in the New York Department of State business entity database. A generic answer like “Locksmith Service” is a warning sign.
  • A local address. Mobile locksmiths often work from a vehicle rather than a storefront, which is normal. But the business should still have a real local address, not a mailbox in another state.
  • Proof of insurance. Ask whether they carry liability insurance and whether they can send a certificate of insurance. Insurance covers accidental damage to your door, frame or vehicle while the technician is working.
  • Whether they are bonded. A surety bond is separate from insurance. It protects you against dishonesty or theft by the business or its employees, which liability insurance does not cover. The answer should be a plain yes or no, not a change of subject.

For reference, our legal entity is My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc., with a mailing address at 38 Mt Hope Ave, Rochester, NY 14620. We are a mobile service, so we come to you rather than running a walk-in storefront. We are bonded and insured, and a certificate of insurance is available on request. Our trustworthy locksmith page explains how we handle identification, quotes and invoices on every job.

How to spot a lead-generation call center

Many locksmith listings online are not locksmiths at all. They are call centers that buy ads under local-sounding names, take your call from another state, and sell the job to whoever will drive out. The person who shows up often has no connection to the company you thought you called.

Signs you may have reached a call center:

  • They answer with a generic greeting instead of a business name.
  • They do not know local street names or the technician who will arrive.
  • The website has stock photos, no owner name and no physical address.
  • They quote a very low price without asking about your lock, door or car.

A simple test is to ask, “Who owns this company, and where are you located?” A local business will answer. A call center usually will not.

Bait pricing and how to avoid it

Bait pricing works like this. You are quoted a very low price on the phone. The technician arrives and announces that your lock is “special” and must be drilled and replaced. The final bill is many times the quote. You can protect yourself before anyone is dispatched:

  • Ask for a quote range, not a single number, and what would push the price toward the top of it.
  • Ask what the quote includes and whether anything could be added to it once the technician is on site. The answer should be specific, not “it depends.”
  • Ask about drilling. Most home and car lockouts can be opened without destroying the lock. Be cautious if someone says drilling is the only option before looking.
  • Confirm the quote when the technician arrives, before any work begins. If it does not match, you are allowed to say no.

What to check when the technician arrives

The phone call is only half the check. A few things at the door tell you whether you reached the business you intended to reach.

  • Identification. Ask for a name and the company the technician works for. It should match the business name you were given on the phone.
  • The quote, repeated. Have the technician state the price before touching the lock. If a higher number appears now, ask why, and do not feel pressured to proceed.
  • A look before a verdict. A technician should inspect the lock, door or car before saying what method is needed. “We have to drill it” announced from the driveway is a bad sign.
  • Your right to decline. Until work starts, you can send anyone away. Nobody is owed the job because they drove out.

Check Google and BBB profiles

Google Business Profile. Search the business name and look at the profile, not just the ad. Check that the address matches what you were told, that reviews mention real Rochester-area jobs, and how the owner responds to negative reviews.

Better Business Bureau. Search the business on bbb.org. The profile shows how long it has been on file, whether it is accredited, its rating, and any complaints. We have been BBB Accredited since 2018 with an A+ rating, and we are a member of ALOA, the Associated Locksmiths of America. Those are records you can verify yourself in a minute, and you should.

Get an itemized invoice

When the work is done, ask for an itemized invoice before you pay. It should show the legal business name and address, the date, the service performed, parts with brand and model, labor, and an explanation of anything that was not in the original quote. Keep it. If a lock fails under warranty or you need to question the bill later, this is the document you will need. Ask about the warranty at the same time. Any locksmith should tell you clearly what is covered and for how long, and that should appear on the invoice too.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal for a locksmith to work in Rochester without a license?

Yes. New York State does not issue a locksmith license, and Monroe County does not require one. Only New York City and Nassau County do. That is why checking the business name, address, insurance and bond matters so much here.

How fast should a Rochester locksmith arrive for an emergency?

For emergency calls in the Rochester area, our response time is 20 to 30 minutes. Whoever you call, ask for an estimated arrival time before dispatch and ask them to call if that changes.

What if the technician who arrives is not from the company I called?

Ask for identification and the name of the company they work for. If it does not match, you can decline the service. Nobody is owed access to your property because they drove out.

For more answers, see our Rochester locksmith FAQs.

Need a locksmith you can check?

My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc. has served Rochester and Monroe County since 2010. We are a mobile service, open 24 hours a day, every day, and our technicians are background checked. Whether you need a home lockout opened, a lock change, or emergency locksmith help, call (585) 360-0131 or reach us through our contact page.

Rekey or Replace? What to Do With the Locks When You Buy a Home in Monroe County

You signed the papers and got the keys. The question most new owners skip is this: who else has a copy? Over the years, keys go to agents, cleaners, contractors, tenants and relatives, and few come back.

Changing who can open your doors is one of the first things to do after closing. You have two traditional ways to do it, rekeying or replacing, and a third option, a smart lock. This guide explains each, with the details that matter for the kinds of houses you find around Rochester, so you can decide what fits your new home. Our residential locksmith team handles all three.

Why closing day is the moment to act

In New York, a home sale closes with attorneys on both sides. The deed is signed at the closing table, and that is where the seller’s keys, garage remotes and alarm codes change hands. Until that moment the house still belongs to the seller, so there is no earlier point at which you can change the locks. Once the deed is yours, there is no reason to wait.

Many Monroe County buyers close in the morning and move in the same afternoon. If that is your plan, book the locksmith for the same day, ideally before the moving truck arrives. If you are closing from out of town, schedule the visit for the day you arrive and ask the movers not to leave belongings in the house before the locks are changed.

What rekeying means

Rekeying keeps your existing hardware. A locksmith removes the cylinder, swaps the small pins inside to match a new key, and reassembles it. The old keys stop working. From the outside, nothing looks different.

Rekeying also lets you put several locks on one key. If the front door, back door and garage entry each came with a different key, a locksmith can usually pin them to match, as long as they share a compatible keyway. Our lock rekey service covers this work across Rochester and Monroe County.

The keyway question comes up often in Rochester’s older city neighborhoods. A pre-war house in the 19th Ward, Park Avenue or the South Wedge may have picked up a Kwikset knob on one door and a Schlage deadbolt on another over decades of owners. Those two brands use different keyways. A locksmith can rekey each to its own fresh key, but putting them on a single key means changing one of the cylinders to match the other.

What replacing means

Replacing removes the lock entirely and installs new hardware. You get a new cylinder, new keys and new exterior parts. This is the right choice when the lock itself is the problem, not just the key.

Replacement is also your chance to step up in quality. Builder-grade locks on many homes offer limited resistance to picking, bumping or forced entry. If you want pick-resistant cylinders and controlled key duplication, our high security locks page covers brands such as Medeco and Mul-T-Lock. See our lock change service for what a full replacement involves, and lock installation for doors that never had a proper lock.

What the common Monroe County house types tend to need

The right mix of rekeying and replacing depends a lot on the age and layout of the house. A few patterns come up again and again in this area.

  • Postwar ranches and split-levels in Greece, Irondequoit, Gates and Henrietta. Built mostly in the 1950s through the 1970s, these usually have an attached garage, which means three or four exterior doors: the front door, a back door or patio slider, the garage service door to the yard, and the door from the garage into the kitchen. The front door lock is often fine to rekey. The garage service door is frequently original, weathered and worth replacing.
  • Hillside houses with walkout basements in Pittsford, Penfield and Perinton. The walkout door sits at the back, below the main floor and out of sight from the street. When the basement was finished, it often received the cheapest lock available. Treat it as a main entry, because an intruder would.
  • Pre-war city houses in Rochester. Many still have an old mortise lock in the front door, with a modern deadbolt added above it at some point. The mortise lock usually cannot be keyed to the deadbolt. A common solution is to leave the old lock as a latch, rekey or replace the deadbolt, and rely on the deadbolt for security.
  • Newer subdivisions in Webster, Chili and Henrietta. During construction, builders, framers, painters and inspectors all used the same key for months. New hardware may be in good shape, so a rekey is often all that is needed, but it should not be skipped just because the house is new.

Rekey or replace: how to decide

Rekeying makes sense when:

  • The locks work well and you like how they look.
  • The hardware is a decent grade and you simply want to cut off old keys.
  • You want one key for every exterior door and the locks share a keyway.

Replacing makes sense when:

  • A lock sticks, grinds, or needs the key jiggled to turn.
  • The hardware is worn, rusted, loose or damaged.
  • The existing locks are a low grade and you want stronger protection.
  • You want features the old locks cannot offer, such as a keypad.

Many homes end up with a mix: rekey the solid locks and replace the tired ones in the same visit.

Who might still have a key

Think about everyone who had access during the previous ownership.

  • Previous owners and their family. Adult children, former spouses and relatives often kept a copy.
  • Real estate agents. During the listing, the key sat in a lockbox that many agents could open, and copies are easy to cut.
  • Contractors and inspectors. Repair crews frequently receive a key for the length of a job.
  • Cleaners, dog walkers and house sitters. Anyone who visited on a schedule usually had a key.
  • Former tenants. If the house was ever rented, past tenants and their guests may hold copies. This is common with the two-family houses and student rentals near the University of Rochester and in the neighborhoods around Monroe Avenue.
  • Neighbors. The spare left for emergencies rarely comes back when the house sells.

Sellers cannot hand over the copies they forgot about. Rekeying or replacing resets the count to zero.

Smart locks as a third option

A smart lock or keypad deadbolt replaces the question of who has a key with the question of who has a code. You can set a code for each person, change it in minutes, and delete it when a contractor finishes or a guest leaves. Many models still accept a physical key as a backup.

Smart locks do add things to think about: batteries, door alignment, and whether the lock fits your existing bore holes. Our keyless door locks page explains the main types and what installation involves.

What Rochester winters do to doors and smart locks

Winter here is hard on exterior doors, and that matters more once a motor is doing the work of turning the bolt. Keep these points in mind if you choose a keypad or smart lock for a Monroe County home.

  • Door alignment. Wood doors and frames move with the seasons. A bolt that slides freely in September can bind against the strike plate in January. A keyed lock lets you push on the door and force it; a smart lock motor will often just stall and report a jam. Have the door, hinges and strike adjusted before the lock is installed.
  • Batteries. Battery life drops in the cold, and the lock works harder when the door is tight. Choose a model with a low-battery warning and a mechanical key override, and keep a key somewhere you can reach it without going inside.
  • Snow and ice at the keypad. A keypad on a door with no overhang takes the full weather. A storm door or a small roof over the entry protects both the lock and the person standing there in a lake-effect squall.
  • Frozen locks. On conventional locks, moisture in the cylinder can freeze overnight. A graphite or dry lubricant helps; oil-based products attract grit and make it worse.

The doors people forget

Most buyers stop at the front door. Secure these too:

  • The garage side door. Attached garages often have a service door to the yard that nobody has touched in years.
  • The door from the garage into the house. If an opener remote is still out there, this interior door is the real barrier.
  • Basement and walkout doors. Below-grade entries are out of sight and easy to overlook, especially on the hillside lots described above.
  • Sliding patio doors. The factory latch is often the weakest point on the house.

Also reset the garage door opener so only your remotes work.

How to prepare for the locksmith visit

  • Count every exterior door, including the garage, basement and outbuildings. Note which ones you want on a single key.
  • Gather every key the sellers left and label which door each one fits.
  • Test each lock and note any that stick or feel loose. Those are candidates for replacement.
  • Decide how many new keys you need for the household.
  • Have proof of ownership ready, such as the closing documents from your attorney or a utility bill in your name. A locksmith should confirm you have the right to change the locks.
  • Clear access to each door so the technician can work on both sides.

If you are moving from out of the area, schedule the visit for the day you arrive.

Frequently asked questions

Does rekeying weaken the lock?

No. Rekeying changes the pins inside the cylinder to match a new key. The lock’s strength comes from its design and build, which stay the same.

Can every lock in the house be put on one key?

Often, but not always. Locks from different manufacturers may use different keyways. A locksmith can tell you which locks can share a key and which would need to be replaced to match.

Should I rekey if the sellers said they gave me every key?

Yes. Sellers can only hand over the keys they remember. Copies given to contractors, cleaners or relatives over the years are the ones nobody tracks.

How soon after closing should the locks be changed?

Ideally on closing day or before you move your belongings in. Until then, anyone with an old key can still enter.

Can the old mortise lock on my city house be rekeyed?

Sometimes. Many older mortise locks can be rekeyed or fitted with a new cylinder, but parts for some are no longer made. A locksmith can look at the lock and tell you whether to rekey it, keep it as a latch, or replace it.

Ready to secure your new home?

My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc. is a mobile service. We come to you anywhere in Rochester and Monroe County, 24 hours a day, every day of the year. Ask about our warranty on installed hardware.

Call (585) 360-0131 or contact us online to schedule a rekey, lock change or keypad installation for your new home.

Locked Out in Rochester at 2 a.m.: What Actually Happens When You Call a Locksmith

It is 2 a.m. You are on your porch, the door is locked, and your keys are on the other side of it. Here is what happens next, step by step, so you know what to expect and what to ask.

Step 1: Make the call

My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc. answers the phone 24 hours a day, every day, at (585) 360-0131. The call goes faster if you have a few things ready before you dial:

  • Your exact location, including any apartment or unit number and anything that helps a driver find the right door in the dark.
  • What kind of door and lock you are looking at, if you can tell. A knob lock, a deadbolt and a keypad are different jobs.
  • Whether anyone inside needs help right away. Say so first if a child, a pet or a stove left on is involved.
  • How you will show you live there once the door is open. More on that in step 6.

Emergency calls in the Rochester area are typically reached in 20 to 30 minutes. The service area covers Rochester and Monroe County, including Greece, Henrietta, Irondequoit, Brighton, Pittsford, Webster, Fairport, Chili, Penfield and Victor. See the emergency locksmith page for what counts as an emergency.

Step 2: What to ask before you hang up

Lockouts are when overcharging happens most, because people are tired and want it over. Ask these while you are still on the phone, whoever you are calling.

  • What is the company’s legal name? You want the name that appears on the invoice and the insurance, not just a brand that shows up in search. Ours is My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc.
  • Is the company insured, and can I see the certificate? We are bonded and insured, and a certificate of insurance is available on request.
  • How is the price put together? Ask what a standard lockout is likely to total and what would change it. Get the answer before anyone arrives, not after the door is open.
  • Who is coming? Our technicians are background checked.

One question you may have seen recommended online does not apply here. New York State has no statewide locksmith license; a few downstate jurisdictions such as New York City and Nassau County have local licensing. A Rochester locksmith therefore has no state license number to show you, so a claimed New York State license number is a warning sign rather than a credential. Judge the company on its legal name, insurance, reviews and how clearly it answers you. Our page on choosing a trustworthy locksmith goes into more detail.

Step 3: The door gets looked at before it gets touched

Whoever shows up, the door deserves a look before any tool comes out. A lockout is not one job. It is several possible jobs, and the details decide which one you have:

  • The type and brand of lock, and whether there is a second lock on the door.
  • Whether the door is only latched or actually deadbolted. A latched door is usually the simpler case.
  • The condition of the door, frame and strike plate. A swollen door or a bent strike changes the approach.
  • Whether a back door, garage or window was left unlocked. It happens more often than people expect, and it is the fastest way in.

If a technician reaches for a drill before looking at any of this, that is your cue to ask questions. A careful look at the door is what tells you whether tonight is a standard lockout or something harder, and you should hear that assessment before work begins.

Step 4: Opening the door without damaging it

For most residential locks, there are ways to open the door that leave the lock working and your key still fitting afterward. Picking, bypass tools and similar methods work with the lock rather than against it. This is the outcome you want from a lockout: the door is open, nothing is broken, and the only thing that has changed is where your keys are.

If someone tells you a standard residential deadbolt has to be drilled before anything else is tried, ask why. There are good reasons to drill, covered in the next step, but speed for the technician’s sake is not one of them.

Step 5: When a lock has to be drilled

Sometimes drilling is the right answer:

  • A high security lock built to resist picking and bypass, such as a Medeco or Mul-T-Lock cylinder.
  • A lock that is broken inside, so it will not turn even with the correct key.
  • A worn or seized lock where non-destructive methods have failed.
  • Someone inside needs help and speed matters more than the hardware.

Drilling destroys the cylinder, which then has to be replaced. Before anything is drilled, ask why it is necessary and what the replacement hardware and labor will cost, so the price you discussed on the phone does not change without your knowledge. If a high security cylinder is involved, expect the replacement to cost more than a standard one, because resistance to drilling and picking is what that hardware is for.

Step 6: Proving you live there

Once the door is open, do not be surprised if you are asked to show that you belong at that address. Across the trade, this is the check that separates a responsible locksmith from someone who will open any door for anyone, and it protects you as much as it protects the next person. A photo ID with the address, or a piece of mail, lease or utility bill you can now step inside to get, is the usual way to settle it. If you rent and nothing has your name on it, having the landlord’s or property manager’s number handy helps.

Think of it this way: if a stranger could get your door opened at 2 a.m. with nothing more than a phone call, your lock would not be worth much. The question is a small inconvenience in exchange for that not being possible.

Step 7: The next morning

Now that you can think clearly, a few things are worth doing:

  • Find the keys. If they are lost rather than left inside, have the lock rekeyed. A rekey keeps your hardware and makes the old keys useless.
  • Decide if the lock was good enough. If it opened quickly, that was convenient last night and less reassuring in general. A lock change to a stronger deadbolt is worth discussing.
  • Consider a keypad. With a keyless lock, keys left inside are no longer a problem.
  • Make a spare and keep it somewhere that is not inside the house. A trusted neighbor or a family member across town is a better plan than a flowerpot by the door.
  • Keep the invoice. It should show the company’s legal name, the work done and any warranty terms for hardware that was installed.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to show ID to a locksmith?

Expect to. A responsible locksmith has good reason to ask for proof of residence once the door is open, and the question works in your favor. Have an ID, a piece of mail or your landlord’s number ready.

Will my lock be damaged?

For most standard residential locks, it should not be. Opening the door without damage is the normal outcome of a lockout. Drilling is generally reserved for high security cylinders, broken or seized locks and situations where someone inside needs help quickly. If drilling is proposed, ask why before it starts.

Can a Rochester locksmith show me a license number?

Not a New York State one, because the state does not issue them. A few downstate jurisdictions such as New York City and Nassau County have local licensing, but that does not reach Rochester or Monroe County. Ask for the legal company name and proof of insurance instead.

Do you handle car and business lockouts at night too?

Yes. Car lockouts and business lockouts are handled 24 hours a day along with home lockouts. The questions in this article apply to all three: ask for the legal name, ask how the price is put together, and ask why before anything is drilled.

Locked out right now?

Call (585) 360-0131. The line is open 24 hours a day, every day, and emergency calls in the Rochester area are typically reached in 20 to 30 minutes. My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc. was founded in 2010, is a member of ALOA (Associated Locksmiths of America), and has been BBB Accredited since 2018 with an A+ rating. If you would rather write, use the contact page, or read more on the home lockout page.

How to find a Trustworthy Locksmith

How to Find a Trustworthy Locksmith

Are you looking for a trustworthy locksmith near you?
Most of the time when someone needs a locksmith, it is usually when they least expect it. Unfortunately, most of us make rash decisions without actually researching the company that we choose for the job. Therefore, most of these cases end up with unsatisfied customers for many reasons. Such as: prices being too high compared to the market fair price, or you ended up buying locks that have been damaged or replaced for no reason.

Continue reading “How to Find a Trustworthy Locksmith” →