When you are locked out, you do not have much time to research, and some of the worst operators in this trade count on that. A few minutes of checking before you give someone your address can save you from a bad job or a surprise bill. This guide applies to any locksmith in Rochester or Monroe County, including us.
Start here: New York State does not license locksmiths
Many people assume a state license is the first filter. In Rochester, there is no such filter. New York State issues no locksmith license. The only places in the state that require one are New York City and Nassau County. Anywhere in Monroe County, whether you are in the city, Greece or Webster, there is no license a locksmith could hold. A company that advertises one is either confused or hoping you will not check. You need to verify a business a different way.
Four things to ask for instead
These four questions take under a minute on the phone, and a real local business can answer all of them.
- The legal business name. Ask what name will appear on your invoice, then look it up in the New York Department of State business entity database. A generic answer like “Locksmith Service” is a warning sign.
- A local address. Mobile locksmiths often work from a vehicle rather than a storefront, which is normal. But the business should still have a real local address, not a mailbox in another state.
- Proof of insurance. Ask whether they carry liability insurance and whether they can send a certificate of insurance. Insurance covers accidental damage to your door, frame or vehicle while the technician is working.
- Whether they are bonded. A surety bond is separate from insurance. It protects you against dishonesty or theft by the business or its employees, which liability insurance does not cover. The answer should be a plain yes or no, not a change of subject.
For reference, our legal entity is My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc., with a mailing address at 38 Mt Hope Ave, Rochester, NY 14620. We are a mobile service, so we come to you rather than running a walk-in storefront. We are bonded and insured, and a certificate of insurance is available on request. Our trustworthy locksmith page explains how we handle identification, quotes and invoices on every job.
How to spot a lead-generation call center
Many locksmith listings online are not locksmiths at all. They are call centers that buy ads under local-sounding names, take your call from another state, and sell the job to whoever will drive out. The person who shows up often has no connection to the company you thought you called.
Signs you may have reached a call center:
- They answer with a generic greeting instead of a business name.
- They do not know local street names or the technician who will arrive.
- The website has stock photos, no owner name and no physical address.
- They quote a very low price without asking about your lock, door or car.
A simple test is to ask, “Who owns this company, and where are you located?” A local business will answer. A call center usually will not.
Bait pricing and how to avoid it
Bait pricing works like this. You are quoted a very low price on the phone. The technician arrives and announces that your lock is “special” and must be drilled and replaced. The final bill is many times the quote. You can protect yourself before anyone is dispatched:
- Ask for a quote range, not a single number, and what would push the price toward the top of it.
- Ask what the quote includes and whether anything could be added to it once the technician is on site. The answer should be specific, not “it depends.”
- Ask about drilling. Most home and car lockouts can be opened without destroying the lock. Be cautious if someone says drilling is the only option before looking.
- Confirm the quote when the technician arrives, before any work begins. If it does not match, you are allowed to say no.
What to check when the technician arrives
The phone call is only half the check. A few things at the door tell you whether you reached the business you intended to reach.
- Identification. Ask for a name and the company the technician works for. It should match the business name you were given on the phone.
- The quote, repeated. Have the technician state the price before touching the lock. If a higher number appears now, ask why, and do not feel pressured to proceed.
- A look before a verdict. A technician should inspect the lock, door or car before saying what method is needed. “We have to drill it” announced from the driveway is a bad sign.
- Your right to decline. Until work starts, you can send anyone away. Nobody is owed the job because they drove out.
Check Google and BBB profiles
Google Business Profile. Search the business name and look at the profile, not just the ad. Check that the address matches what you were told, that reviews mention real Rochester-area jobs, and how the owner responds to negative reviews.
Better Business Bureau. Search the business on bbb.org. The profile shows how long it has been on file, whether it is accredited, its rating, and any complaints. We have been BBB Accredited since 2018 with an A+ rating, and we are a member of ALOA, the Associated Locksmiths of America. Those are records you can verify yourself in a minute, and you should.
Get an itemized invoice
When the work is done, ask for an itemized invoice before you pay. It should show the legal business name and address, the date, the service performed, parts with brand and model, labor, and an explanation of anything that was not in the original quote. Keep it. If a lock fails under warranty or you need to question the bill later, this is the document you will need. Ask about the warranty at the same time. Any locksmith should tell you clearly what is covered and for how long, and that should appear on the invoice too.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal for a locksmith to work in Rochester without a license?
Yes. New York State does not issue a locksmith license, and Monroe County does not require one. Only New York City and Nassau County do. That is why checking the business name, address, insurance and bond matters so much here.
How fast should a Rochester locksmith arrive for an emergency?
For emergency calls in the Rochester area, our response time is 20 to 30 minutes. Whoever you call, ask for an estimated arrival time before dispatch and ask them to call if that changes.
What if the technician who arrives is not from the company I called?
Ask for identification and the name of the company they work for. If it does not match, you can decline the service. Nobody is owed access to your property because they drove out.
For more answers, see our Rochester locksmith FAQs.
Need a locksmith you can check?
My Locksmith Rochester NY Inc. has served Rochester and Monroe County since 2010. We are a mobile service, open 24 hours a day, every day, and our technicians are background checked. Whether you need a home lockout opened, a lock change, or emergency locksmith help, call (585) 360-0131 or reach us through our contact page.
